CrossFit Coaching Tip: Despite Consistent Attendance, An Athlete Shows No Visible Progress In Strength, Skills, Or Conditioning. What Do You Do?

By

Eric O'Connor CF-L4

August 24, 2025

Situation: Despite consistent attendance, an athlete shows no visible progress in strength, skills, or conditioning. What do you do?

Solution: Plateaus occur during every athlete’s training journey, but premature plateaus can be avoided with these tools.

  1. Address Lifestyle Factors. Since they train consistently, look outside the gym. Assess nutrition, sleep, and stress levels. Start with nutrition consistency — quality foods and balanced macronutrients. If eating well, consider tracking intake using CrossFit Nutrition 1 Course parameters. For sleep, evaluate quantity and quality — average hours and nightly disturbances. Improve through consistent bedtime routines and regular sleep/wake schedules. See this interview with Dr. Allison Brager for more information on the value of sleep and variables to consider to enhance sleep quality. 
  2. Refine Your Coaching. Review movement patterns — athletes often plateau due to compensatory patterns that limit efficiency. Address nuanced movement factors to unlock potential. Continue challenging athletes and encouraging intensity. Combat complacency by adding 5 pounds when they hesitate or setting goal times just beyond their current reach. 
  3. Vary Scaling Approaches. Athletes plateau when routinely scaling the same way (reducing reps/load, same gymnastics modifications). Provide alternative scaling options. For example, use Rx’d weight, but reduce reps, or vary modification patterns to maintain challenge and progression. 
  4. Target Programming. Address specific weaknesses by increasing frequency in that domain. If strength is lacking, add a second designated strength day weekly. Use warm-ups and cool-downs for skill development — like 5-10 minutes of handstand progressions one to two times weekly for 12 weeks.

Key Point: Plateaus are multifactorial. Address lifestyle first, then refine coaching and programming approaches systematically.

What would you do?

Let us know in the comments.

Related Content


About the Author

Eric O'Connor (CF-L4)

Eric O’Connor is a Content Developer and Seminar Staff Flowmaster for CrossFit’s Education Department and the co-creator of the former CrossFit Competitor’s Course. He has led over 400 seminars and has more than a decade of experience coaching at a CrossFit affiliate. He is a Certified CrossFit Coach (CF-L4), a former Division 1 collegiate wrestler, and a former CrossFit Games athlete.