Skip to Content

Search

Effectiveness and Safety of a Novel Care Model for the Management of Type 2 Diabetes at 1 Year

3
ByCrossFitMay 14, 2019

This 2018 trial, funded by Virta Health, tested the impact of a high-compliance ketogenic diet on metabolic outcomes in Type 2 diabetics.

Existing evidence (some of which has been previously reviewed on CrossFit.com) suggests low-carbohydrate diets, especially ketogenic diets, can produce rapid and clinically meaningful reductions in blood sugar and other metabolic markers in Type 2 diabetics. Many real-world trials of ketogenic diets, however, show comparatively limited benefits, as many diabetics struggle to follow a ketogenic diet without substantial support. As a result, there is little to no evidence of the impact of a ketogenic diet on diabetes over a longer duration.

In this trial, 262 Type 2 diabetics were counseled to follow a diet that would achieve and sustain nutritional ketosis (i.e., blood BHB of 0.5 – 3.0 mmol/L). Each subject was given personalized, dynamic dietary guidance by a health coach who continuously communicated with each subject and tracked biomarkers via an app. As such, the specific diet varied by subject but generally involved 1.5 g/kg of protein intake and <30 g of carbohydrate intake per day, alongside non-starchy vegetables, multivitamins, and adequate fluids. Of the original 262 subjects, 218 completed one year of treatment.

At baseline, 93% of subjects were obese and 57% were on a diabetes medication other than metformin. Over one year, treated subjects showed the following outcomes:

  • Reduction in HbA1c from 7.6% to 6.3%
  • Reductions in fasting glucose (-22%), fasting insulin (-43%), and C-peptide (-23%)
  • Reductions in triglycerides (-24%), C-reactive protein (-39%), ALT (-30%) and AST (-21%)
  • Increases in HDL-C (18%) and LDL-C (10%)
  • Mean weight loss of 13.8 kg

All of the above outcomes were statistically significant.

Figure 1

Figure 1

Nearly half of all subjects were able to discontinue their diabetes medication, including 40% of those taking insulin. Mean insulin dose among those still taking insulin at one year decreased from 105.2 to 53.8 units per day.

Sixty percent of participants reduced their HbA1c to <6.5% and were off all diabetes medication or down to metformin only at the end of the study; they therefore no longer met the criteria for diabetes on the basis of HbA1c.

Figure 3

Figure 3

The majority of these improvements occurred within the first 70 days of treatment, but blood BHB levels showed subjects maintained mild nutritional ketosis out to one year, which suggests continued compliance with the diet.

A couple of points about this trial need to be noted. First, the trial was funded and run by Virta Health, a private company that sells the app used in the trial to privately insured employers; as such, the trial involves a conflict of interest similar to a pharma-funded drug trial. Additionally, the 262 subjects all chose to opt into the Virta program and were neither randomized nor blinded.

Despite these issues, the significance of this trial can hardly be overstated. This trial represents the first clear, long-term evidence in a large population that a ketogenic diet, when followed properly, can lead to significant improvements in health among Type 2 diabetics, and in many cases (in this trial, the majority) even resolves diabetes completely. In the narrow sense, this demonstrates that Virta’s methodology is a uniquely powerful tool for improving the health of diabetic populations. In the broad sense, it demonstrates that a dietary shift alone can drive rapid, meaningful clinical improvements. It would be reasonable to expect that other diabetics able to comply with a ketogenic diet for one year or more would see similarly dramatic improvements.

Comments on Effectiveness and Safety of a Novel Care Model for the Management of Type 2 Diabetes at 1 Year

Comments 3

Sort By

Mary Dan EadesMay 15th, 2019 at 2:58 pm

Gratifying to see such a profound effect demonstrated under the rigors of study conditions over a year. No mention, that I could see in the study, of exercise (probably by design so as not to obfuscate the findings of what diet alone could do in this population) but as we, who have watched the amazing outcomes in diabetic and pre-diabetic patient after patient on a low-carb diet (not even necessarily a frankly ketogenic one) over the years know, adding resistance training to muscle fatigue (ie anaerobic exercise) greatly improves glucose handling and body-wide metabolic function and would surely have made the results even more dramatic.

Russ GreeneMay 15th, 2019 at 5:20 pm

Great point, Dr. Eades. And if you added metabolic conditioning at relatively high intensity on top of those two (carb restriction + resistance training), I would expect yet more dramatic results.

Nathan JenkinsMay 15th, 2019 at 6:46 pm

Dr. Eades, Russ, I see this as the next frontier in type 2 diabetes & prediabetes research! Nothing that hasn't already been observed in the CrossFit space, but the results of such a trial would be compelling indeed.