CrossFit | 191222
Sunday

191222

Workout of the Day

2

Rest Day

Post thoughts to comments.

Robert Hayden

Read “Those Winter Sundays” by Robert Hayden.

“Evidence on medical interventions only has value when all the data can be seen,” Dr. Malcolm Kendrick claims. Unfortunately, despite some scientists’ attempts to draw attention to the selective reporting of clinical data, negative results often remain unpublished. Kendrick argues, “Evidence-based medicine, and therefore the entire medical research database, has been corrupted to the point that it is not just unhelpful but potentially extremely damaging to health.”

Read MoreEvidence-Based Medicine, Part 2: Unpublished Evidence

Comments on 191222

3 Comments

Comment thread URL copied!
Tyler Hass
December 23rd, 2019 at 3:35 am
Commented on: Evidence-Based Medicine, Part 2: Unpublished Evidence

It’s scary to think there’s a vast body of evidence on medicine that’s unknown and inaccessible to doctors and patients. Whoever controls the purse strings can set the research agenda and to an extent that’s fair. I’m all for free markets, where people and companies allocate their capital as they see fit. But the ability to suppress damaging research and silence dissenters is not good for a free market, nor for science. Much of the reason free markets are so successful is because the free flow of information signals buyers what to buy and producers what to produce more efficiently than any other system. When it comes to drug trials, we need ALL the information.

The government and pharma probably both worry that if information like this were to become public knowledge, it would erode trust in the healthcare system. This rationalization has been used many times before. In fact, Mary Eades shared a great example in a comment on yesterday’s post. A panel of top nutrition experts, including Walter Willet from Harvard, presented evidence onstage that the low fat diet they championed to the American public had failed. Could they admit failure? Would the American public ever trust them again? No, better to stay the course.

I see a parallel with the “too big to fail” reasoning of the financial crisis of 2008 when many of the big banks were on the verge of failure. Just imagine what would happen to the pharmaceutical giants if word got out that several of their cash cow drugs: statins and antidepressants, are not as effective as the public has been led to believe. Would the government let them fail?

Comment URL copied!
Js Smith
December 22nd, 2019 at 11:56 pm
Commented on: 191222

Ran same course as last week, two minutes quicker. Still 🐢 but a faster one.

Comment URL copied!
Steve Pasche
December 22nd, 2019 at 4:53 pm
Commented on: 191222

This poem is so striking to me. Having a child is what taught me what love truly means.

Comment URL copied!